A reading magazine for families, book clubs and anyone with a cup going cold.
Graphic novels that turn reluctant readers around
Comics are real reading, and for a child who has decided books are not for them, they can be the way back in. Here is what the research suggests, and ten graphic novels to try.
Book links go to WorldCat (to find a library copy), Bookshop.org and Amazon.
We don’t earn anything from them at the moment. Our disclosure policy.
Some children decide early that reading is not for them. Sometimes it is because decoding is still slow; sometimes it is attention, or simply that the books in front of them have never once been fun. For many of those children, a graphic novel is the first book they choose for themselves, finish, and ask for the sequel of. That is not a detour from reading. It is reading.
Why graphic novels work for some reluctant readers
A graphic novel splits the work of a story between words and pictures. Faces show feelings that prose would have to describe. Panels set the pace, so a reader always knows where the next small step is. The text on each page is usually short, and a page can be finished quickly, which gives a child who expects to fail a run of small successes.
None of this makes comics “easier” in a dismissive sense. Readers have to track how one panel leads to the next, read expressions and backgrounds, and connect what is said with what is shown. That is inference, and it is the same thinking that supports comprehension in prose.
What the research says, and what it does not
The research on graphic novels and struggling readers is encouraging but small. It is worth knowing what it shows before treating it as settled.
In a classroom study with 24 fifth graders of mixed ability, students read traditional novels, heavily illustrated novels and graphic novels. The graphic novel received the highest scores in all the categories measured, including comprehension and enjoyment, and the researchers concluded graphic novels deserve consideration as an engaging way to teach reading.
A qualitative study in one fourth-grade classroom found children used comprehension strategies while reading graphic novels that could carry over to other kinds of texts, and that their preference for graphic novels grew over the study.
These are small studies in specific classrooms, not large trials, so they cannot tell you that graphic novels will raise any particular child’s reading scores. What they do support is a commonsense view: graphic novels can engage readers who are otherwise disengaged, and they give children real practice with comprehension. If decoding itself is the problem, a graphic novel will not replace skilled instruction, and it is worth talking to your child’s school about an evaluation.
Ten graphic novels for ages 7 to 14
The list runs roughly from youngest to oldest. Ages come from the publisher where it gives one; otherwise they are our own judgment, which the fact-check note above records.
Book
Ages
Type
Text load
Narwhal: Unicorn of the Sea!
6–9
Funny early graphic novel
Very light
Babymouse: Queen of the World!
7–10
Funny school story
Light
Dog Man
7–10
Slapstick superhero
Light
Hilo: The Boy Who Crashed to Earth
8–12
Sci-fi action
Light to moderate
El Deafo
8–12
Memoir
Moderate
Roller Girl
9–12
Sports and friendship
Moderate
New Kid
9–13
Realistic school story
Moderate
Swim Team
8–12
Sports with history
Moderate
When Stars Are Scattered
9–12
True story, refugee camp
Moderate
Smile
10–14
Memoir
Moderate
Just starting out
For a child who has only just learned to read alone, the shortest, sunniest place to begin:
Narwhal: Unicorn of the Sea! (A Narwhal and Jelly Book #1)Clanton
Narwhal: Unicorn of the Sea! (A Narwhal and Jelly Book #1)
by Ben Clanton, illustrated by Ben Clanton
Ages
6–9
Publisher
Tundra Books
First published
2016
Format
Paperback, 64 pages
Series
Narwhal and Jelly
ISBN-13
9781101918715
Why it’s here. A cheerful narwhal and a no-nonsense jellyfish share three short, silly stories about friendship, waffles and imagination. Big panels, few words per page and stories that end quickly make it a low-risk first graphic novel for a newly independent reader.
Keep in mind. It is aimed at the youngest end of this list; most children over eight will find it too young. The humor is gentle and whimsical rather than loud.
For a reader who likes a heroine with a big imagination and a narrator who argues back:
Babymouse #1: Queen of the World!Holm
Babymouse #1: Queen of the World!
by Jennifer L. Holm, illustrated by Matthew Holm
Ages
7–10
Publisher
Random House Graphic
First published
2005
Format
Paperback, 96 pages
Series
Babymouse
ISBN-13
9780375832291
Why it’s here. Babymouse is bored with ordinary life and desperate for an invitation to Felicia Furrypaws's slumber party, even if it means letting down her best friend, Wilson. Her daydreams spill into the panels as fantasy sequences, and the narrator talks back to her, which rewards a child who likes jokes on two levels.
Keep in mind. The pink-and-black art and the heroine may lead some boys to dismiss it, which is their loss but worth knowing. Frequent cutaways to daydreams can confuse a child who is new to reading comics panel by panel.
The series that many children credit with getting them reading at all:
Dog ManPilkey
Dog Man
by Dav Pilkey, illustrated by Dav Pilkey
Ages
7–10
Publisher
Graphix
First published
2016
Format
Hardcover
Series
Dog Man
ISBN-13
9780545581608
Why it’s here. After an accident, a police officer and his dog are stitched together into Dog Man, who fights crime and chases squirrels in a comic presented as the work of two kid cartoonists, George and Harold. Slapstick, flip-o-rama pages and a deliberately kid-made look have pulled huge numbers of children into reading on their own.
Keep in mind. Intentional misspellings in the "kid-made" comic bother some parents and teachers of beginning spellers, and the potty humor and cartoon violence are constant. It is light on story depth, which is the point but will not stretch a confident reader.
For a child who wants robots, explosions and jokes, with a heart underneath:
Hilo Book 1: The Boy Who Crashed to EarthWinick
Hilo Book 1: The Boy Who Crashed to Earth
by Judd Winick, illustrated by Judd Winick
Ages
8–12
Publisher
Random House Graphic
First published
2015
Format
Hardcover, 208 pages
Series
Hilo
ISBN-13
9780385386173
Why it’s here. Hilo falls out of the sky with no memory of where he came from, and two ordinary kids, D.J. and Gina, try to help him pass as a normal boy while robots and villains follow him to Earth. Fast pacing, bright color and constant jokes make it a strong pick for a child who wants action first.
Keep in mind. There is a lot of robot combat and peril, and some emotionally weightier moments arrive later in the series. Readers who want a realistic school story should start elsewhere on this list.
Memoir and realistic fiction give a reluctant reader the chance to see their own worries on the page. A memoir that uses the comic form itself to show what not hearing feels like:
El DeafoBell
El Deafo
by Cece Bell, illustrated by Cece Bell
Ages
8–12
Publisher
Amulet Books
First published
2014
Format
Hardcover
ISBN-13
9781419710209
Why it’s here. Cece Bell's graphic memoir of losing her hearing after a childhood illness and going to school with a bulky hearing aid strapped to her chest. Everyone is drawn as a rabbit, speech balloons fade or go blank when Cece cannot hear, and the form itself teaches a reader how comics carry meaning.
Keep in mind. Long for a first graphic novel, and the illness, loneliness and teasing are handled honestly. Some Deaf readers and families come to deafness from a different perspective than Bell's personal story, so it is one experience, not a guide.
A summer of roller derby and a friendship coming apart:
Roller GirlJamieson
Roller Girl
by Victoria Jamieson, illustrated by Victoria Jamieson
Ages
9–12
Publisher
Dial Books
First published
2015
Format
Paperback, 256 pages
ISBN-13
9780803740167
Why it’s here. Astrid signs up for roller derby camp and loses her best friend to dance camp in the same summer. A Newbery Honor book, according to its publisher, it is funny, bruising and very good on the feeling of outgrowing a friendship before you are ready.
Keep in mind. Friendship drama and some meanness between girls are central, and derby bumps and bruises are shown with relish. A reader who wants fantasy or adventure may lose interest in the realistic plot.
A sharp, funny school story about fitting in and code-switching:
New KidCraft
New Kid
by Jerry Craft
Ages
9–13
Publisher
HarperCollins
First published
2019
Format
Hardcover, 256 pages
ISBN-13
9780062691200
Why it’s here. Seventh grader Jordan Banks wants to go to art school, but his parents send him to an elite private school where he is one of the few kids of color in his grade. Jordan's own sketchbook pages break up the story, and the book is sharp and funny about microaggressions, class and code-switching between two worlds.
Keep in mind. The humor depends partly on recognizing everyday racial slights, which younger readers may need talked through. With a large cast and many short scenes, it rewards a reader who can keep track of who is who.
Why it’s here. Bree, who cannot swim, ends up in a swim class at her new middle school and, with help from an unexpected mentor, finds her way onto the team. The story weaves in the history of Black Americans being shut out of public pools, giving a sports story real depth without slowing it down.
Keep in mind. Scenes of historical segregation and racism are part of the plot. Readers looking for nonstop action will find it more of a character story with competitions at the end.
For older readers who are ready for a true story about hardship, told with care:
When Stars Are ScatteredJamieson
When Stars Are Scattered
by Victoria Jamieson and Omar Mohamed, illustrated by Victoria Jamieson and Iman Geddy
Ages
9–12
Publisher
Dial Books
First published
2020
Format
Paperback, 264 pages
ISBN-13
9780525553908
Why it’s here. Omar Mohamed's true story of growing up in a refugee camp in Kenya after fleeing Somalia, caring for his younger brother and fighting for a chance at school. A National Book Award finalist, according to its publisher, it is proof that a graphic novel can carry real weight while staying readable.
Keep in mind. War, separation from a parent, hunger and grinding hardship are central, though the book is not graphic in its depiction. It suits a reader ready for a serious, slower story.
And a memoir that has become a rite of passage for many tweens:
SmileTelgemeier
Smile
by Raina Telgemeier, illustrated by Raina Telgemeier
Ages
10–14
Publisher
Graphix
First published
2010
Format
Paperback
ISBN-13
9780545132060
Why it’s here. Raina trips, knocks out her two front teeth and spends years in braces, headgear and surgery while middle school friendships fall apart around her. It is a true story told with warmth, and it has introduced countless tweens to graphic memoir.
Keep in mind. Dental injuries and procedures are shown in detail that squeamish readers may not enjoy. Crushes, unkind friends and early-teen embarrassment are central, so some younger children will not connect with it yet.
Start with your child’s interests, not their reading level. A nine-year-old obsessed with sports may sit happily with Swim Team or Roller Girl even if Dog Man looks closer to their reading level. Put two or three options out and let them choose.
Do not ask a child to “move on to real books” once they are hooked. Graphic novels sit alongside prose, and many readers go back and forth for years. If you want to build a bridge, try a prose book by the same author or on the same subject, or an illustrated hybrid novel, and read the first chapter aloud together.
Read one yourself. Talking about a funny panel or a confusing page is a natural way into conversation about the story, and it tells your child the format is worth an adult’s time too.
If your child loves the pictures but avoids the words entirely, or still struggles to read the speech balloons after months of trying, that is useful information for their teacher. Our guides to reading strategies for kids with ADHD and dyslexia-friendly books and formats cover other kinds of support.
How we checked this
Each book was checked against the publisher's page (Penguin Random House; a Scholastic teaching guide for Dog Man) or its Open Library edition record for title, contributors, imprint, ISBN-13, format, pages and age range. The three studies cited were checked against their ERIC records, and claims are limited to what those abstracts state. Awards are mentioned only where the publisher's page states them. Ages for Dog Man, El Deafo, New Kid, Swim Team and Smile are our own judgment, as the article says.
Each book’s publisher, ISBN and format were checked against the record linked below. Ages are guidance; publishers’ ranges are used where they exist.
What we couldn’t confirm:
Several publisher sites (HarperCollins, Scholastic, Candlewick) blocked automated access; those editions were checked against Open Library or publisher teaching-guide records, and ages for them are our own judgment.
Short plot details for Swim Team, El Deafo and Smile are summarized from general knowledge of the books and were not each confirmed on an opened page.